An electricity meter on the wall of an indoor cannabis facility can tell an engineer how many kilowatt-hours the building used last month. It cannot, on its own, tell her how much carbon dioxide was released to supply them. Put the same equipment a few states away and its demand might change. Even if the monthly meter reading stayed exactly the same, the emissions associated with it could move quite sharply.
Those are two separate geographical effects, and much of the interest in a United States study of indoor cannabis lies in teasing them apart. Hailey Summers, Evan Sproul and Jason Quinn modelled a facility in different locations, accounting for the energy and materials needed to produce a kilogram of dried flower. They could effectively move a building without having to build it twice.
Move the plug first
Imagine, for a moment, a month in which a piece of equipment draws 1,000 kilowatt-hours in each of two buildings. Give the first grid an illustrative emissions rate of 0.2 kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent per kilowatt-hour and the second a rate of 0.6. Our identical meter readings now represent 200 and 600 kilograms respectively. The rates here are invented to make the units visible. An actual comparison needs data for the right places and period. The EPA sets out the calculation in its guide to emissions from purchased electricity.
Electricity can reach the same outlet from different mixes of generators. The US Environmental Protection Agency’s eGRID database reports electricity generation and associated emissions, including regional rates useful for this sort of accounting. A regional average answers a question about the electricity supply over the reporting period. It provides a different piece of information from a measurement of which generator responded to a particular building switching its equipment on at noon.
Now move the whole building
The second move changes the reading on the meter. Lamps release heat indoors. Plants release moisture into the air. Air entering a building brings the local weather with it. To maintain the same indoor environment, a facility in a hot, humid place faces a different load from one in a cool, dry place. Outdoor temperature alone cannot tell an engineer how much work the equipment has to do. Removing water from the air takes energy too.
A heating bill may also arrive separately from the electricity bill. A facility that burns fuel on site can have emissions that never appear in its electricity total. Colorado’s environmental guide to cannabis facilities describes the interaction of heating, ventilation, cooling and dehumidification. In a building full of equipment giving off heat, a cooler day outdoors need not translate into a predictable change across all four systems.
Reading a number per kilogram
The researchers used a cradle-to-gate boundary. That term tells readers where to begin and end the tally. Their calculation includes upstream burdens associated with inputs as well as activities at the facility, and stops when the product leaves production. Electricity, natural gas and supplied carbon dioxide all figured in the analysis. Retail operations and a purchaser’s trip home lie beyond that boundary.
There is also a denominator to inspect. Suppose two sites have the same annual emissions and one produces less dried flower. Its calculated emissions per kilogram will rise even though its annual total matches the other’s. For a real facility, comparing model assumptions about output and equipment with records of production and energy use is at least as important as finding the correct dot on the map.
The model’s range across US locations describes the consequences of supplying an indoor process under different conditions. It would be a mistake to treat it as a league table of individual businesses. Faced with two facilities and two meter readings, the engineer would still ask for three things before giving an answer: the source of their electricity, their other fuel use, and the amount of flower that actually left each building.